Guildford looks compact on a map because it is. You can walk from the station to the High Street in minutes, continue towards the Castle Grounds, or cross town for Stoke Park without turning the evening into a journey. That makes first dates easier. It also means vague location labels are not much use.
Someone listed simply as “Surrey” might live close by, or they might be an hour away once traffic, rail changes and the reality of weekday schedules are counted. This Guildford dating site keeps its focus tighter. Surrey has a separate site for people who want the wider county.
The town has its own rhythm. Many commuters are not properly free until after seven. Parents may need more notice. People working at the university, hospital, business parks, shops and local schools often have completely different hours. A useful profile says more than “I like eating out”. Try something practical: “Usually free after 7.30 on weekdays, happy to meet near the station or in town.” That small detail removes several rounds of messages.
A good local match is not merely nearby on a map. They are nearby when both of you are actually available.
For single people in Godalming, the train into Guildford can make a meeting workable, but it is still worth being clear about where you want to date. If you prefer everything to happen in Godalming, say so. If Guildford is part of your normal week, say that instead. Honest logistics are far more useful than pretending distance never matters.